hi novaking,
i guess this is the reason why so many of my suggestions were marked as 'more to do with
episodes'. but i don't see the show information page purely as providing information (despite the
name you give it), i see it as also or even primarily grouping the episodes of a particular show
on to one page, and certainly when i've introduced people to eztv that seems to be the way they
use it - they open the show information page of whatever show they are particularly interested in
and start downloading episodes either from where they stopped watching or from the start.
frankly, if you were just after show information then you could almost just provide a link to imdb
and a link to the imdb or wikipedia episode list and leave it at that - though that underestimates
the sterling work boonesferry and others do to relate the scene names to actual episodes, and
unknot any mistakes, and i would certainly not choose to have it that way! 🙂
if you look at my suggestions in that light then perhaps more of them are related to the show
information page - they are designed to make downloading from a single page a chunk of episodes
for a particular show, in a particular format, easier, and to avoid downloads of problem files when
there are more than one choice (eg the first file, the real, the proper, the really real, the web
rip, the 720p, the 720p's real, and so on), letting them get exactly what they need and want, all
on one handy page - and they can read about the show itself too, though that is not really a
priority for existing shows they already know.
because while i have been using your site for ages and read the titles of files with the same ease
that i read my own handwriting, beginners at the site (as i have noticed when introducing them to
it) do not. in that context, a separate column for eg 720p, and sorting and filing, and my other
suggestions make more sense.
yes, i am very aware that many or most of my suggestions would also apply to the other
pages on the site, and i won't deny i would like to see the same suggestions implemented
elsewhere - heck, i even acknowledged that at one point, saying 'aside from wanting that in the
show information page i am absolutely and unashamedly angling to have that info handy for later
revisions of other parts of the site such as the search!'.
but the show information page is, to my knowledge, the only page on the site where all the
episodes of a show are gathered together within one click of the front page (you can achieve the
same with the search but that requires two clicks and some scrolling, or some typing and a click)
and it is often used as such by both experienced users and beginners, and i think that it should be
viewed in that light as well as just providing information on the show.
perhaps it would be better called the 'show' page.
just a thought.... thanks for all your amazing work, good luck with the redesign!
